Aly is the author of People Like Us: How Arrogance is Dividing Islam and the West, which was shortlisted for several awards including Best Newcomer at the 2008 ABIA (Australian Book Industry Awards). He has been recognized with various other awards including the Voltaire Award for Free Speech, the United Nations Association of Australia Media Peace Award for Social Cohesion with producer Tom Whitty, and the Golden Logie Award for Best Personality in Australian Television. In 2011 he was named Victoria's Local Hero at the Australian of the Year Awards. He is married to Australian feminist author and academic Dr. Susan Carland, and they have two children.