Untold Tales of the Hasidim

Since the early years of the 20th century, Hasidim has been romanticized . . . and made to convey a profound message for modern readers. Similarly, for their own purposes, Hasidic leaders have made strenuous efforts to purify it of embarrassing incidents. Assaf, a critical scholar of Hasidism at Tel-Aviv Univ., has taken the opposite tack: his sober account, which first appeared in a Hebrew version in 2006, sets out to show a number of less appealing aspects of the movement and to reveal the self-censorship employed by the guardians of its traditions . . . Assaf reveals the various techniques by which these inconvenient truths were--and still are--erased from collective memory. Recommended. -- Choice David Assaf digs deep into a pile of scandals from the 19th and early 20th centuries. The book's title promises tantalizing details that will remove the veil of righteousness from the pious. But this is no mere scandal sheet about a religious group that has jealously guarded nasty secrets from public scrutiny. It is a demanding exercise of historical study that exhaustively analyzes all the evidence surrounding some controversial episodes in an attempt to arrive at a balanced, if belated, truth. . . . History has rightly relegated the scandals Assaf analyzes to footnotes, notable exceptions on the margins of the Hasidic narrative. In Untold Tales of the Hasidim, Assaf corrects those footnotes and provides a lesson in the danger of historians with social or political agendas. -- Commentary Notwithstanding the bifurcated polemical reactions to its Hebrew original, Untold Tales is not an exercise in scoring points either against or for Hasidism. Rather, Assaf, who is careful not to generalize about [Hasidim] as a whole, brings to the fore a gallery of actual, flawed human beings caught between a demanding familial and religious tradition encompassing all aspects of life and the modern values of freedom and individuality. Of course, for most Jews today, the very notion of a binding turmoil has been rendered so obsolete that the agonizing inner turmoil of Assaf's Hasidim is more likely to arouse curiosity than empathy. But for orthodox Jews and others who retain a commitment to the transmission of past wisdom and religious commandment . . . the conflicts that beset this book are bound to resonate. As for those who still adhere to the principle that religious authority trumps intellectual honesty, Assaf's remarkable detective work suggests that, one way or another, cover-ups will eventually be uncovered. -- Jewish Ideas Daily A revised translation of a controversial work of history by a leading Israeli historian of Hasidism, this book looks at little-known or repressed events in Hasidic history in the 19th and early 20th centuries . . . Assaf masterfully explores how historical facts are guarded, repressed, or twisted by Hasidic guardians of traditions, mitnagdic and maskilic opponents as well as by modern historians; and how the winds of modernity touched the traditional Hasidic world in modern times. The book is an important addition to any academic library. -- American Jewish Libraries