""Mary Hall has set the standard for what published diaries of Civil War soldiers should be."" Bradley Gottfried, Ph.D. ""Mary Hall's vociferously researched work, from the National Archives to public and private collections, will quickly find a home in Civil War historiography."" Michael P. Gray, Ph.D. ""Mary Hall's book will intrigue and inform popular and scholarly readers alike . . . [She] provides the historical context and expert analysis in each chapter, and then she lets Hall's and Elsesser's words breathe life into their daily experiences in the Confederate and Union armies."" David Ulbrich, Ph.D.